(Image Credit: iStockPhoto/farakos)
Last month, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) released its net neutrality rules designed to keep the internet open and prevent service providers from discriminating between types of traffic. Among other provisions, the rules prohibit practices like “fast lanes,” where certain services would receive preferential treatment in exchange for payment.
Internet service providers (ISPs) argue that some services—particularly high-bandwidth streaming platforms like Netflix—consume disproportionate amounts of network capacity. ISPs say those services should contribute more toward infrastructure costs or face restrictions that could degrade performance for their customers.
Many ISPs have voiced strong objections to the FCC’s approach, but legal challenges were not possible until today. The rules were published in the Federal Register, the official record of U.S. federal regulations, which opens the door for opponents to seek judicial review.
With the order now formally published, the FCC can expect multiple lawsuits in the coming months. USTelecom, a telecommunications industry trade association, was among the first to file suit, calling the FCC’s open Internet rules “arbitrary” and “capricious.”
USTelecom’s complaint focuses less on the goal of preserving an open Internet and more on the FCC’s change in regulatory approach. The group contends the agency improperly reverted to common carrier regulation, arguing the move is legally unjustified and procedurally flawed.
In its filing, USTelecom asks the court to review the order, characterizing the agency’s action as “an abuse of discretion” under the Administrative Procedure Act. The complaint asserts the FCC’s decision violates federal law, including provisions of the Constitution and the Communications Act of 1934.
The FCC anticipates defending the new rules against most challenges, but industry resistance is expected to be vigorous. Legal disputes over the scope and authority of the FCC’s order are likely to play out in court for months or years.
Do ISPs have a valid legal claim against the FCC’s net neutrality rules? Share your thoughts in the comments.