(Image Credit: iStockPhoto/Andrew Linscott)
Regulators have raised concerns about Three’s proposed £10 billion takeover of O2, arguing the merger would reduce the number of major players in the UK mobile market, weaken competition and risk higher prices for consumers. If approved, the deal would instantly transform Three from the smallest to the largest mobile operator in the UK by subscriber numbers.
Hutchison, which owns Three UK, has offered a series of concessions in recent months to address regulator objections and improve the chances of approval. The company committed to freeze consumer prices for at least five years, pledged an additional £5 billion investment in the network—around 20 percent more than previously planned—and promised to enable “other meaningful competitors” to access and use its network.
Despite these concessions, regulators appear unconvinced. In a further effort to secure approval, Three has proposed an even larger concession: carving off £3 billion worth of network assets to be used by Sky and Virgin Media.
Under the proposal, roughly 30 percent of Three’s network capacity would be allocated to third parties—20 percent to Sky and 10 percent to Virgin Media for a period of ten years. Virgin Media currently operates its mobile offering as an MVNO (mobile virtual network operator) using EE’s network, so access to Three’s infrastructure would represent a significant strategic shift.
European regulators have grown more cautious about market consolidation in recent years, worried that fewer operators could lead to higher consumer prices. Some similar mergers have been approved in countries such as Austria and Ireland, while others have been blocked—examples include the TeliaSonera–Telenor deal in Denmark and Orange–Bouygues Telecom in France.
Last month, research from Morningstar criticised what it called an excessive regulatory fixation on maintaining four MNOs per market, arguing this approach can hinder beneficial mergers. Morningstar specifically challenged the methodology used in a report commissioned by UK regulator Ofcom that examined a Hutchison–Orange merger in Austria. The researchers pointed out two main flaws: first, the report did not adjust for the large increase in data consumption over time, which can mask real price trends when usage is considered; and second, it focused on prices a new customer would pay, overlooking retention incentives offered to existing subscribers.
According to Morningstar, operators have consistently invested in networks to attract higher-value customers, leaving lower-usage customers with MVNOs that primarily compete on price. This dynamic, they argue, can lead to misleading conclusions if studies ignore changes in data consumption and customer segmentation.
Earlier analyses by Dutch and Austrian regulators examined the price effects of past mobile mergers—such as T-Mobile’s acquisitions of tele.ring in 2006 and Orange in 2007. Those studies found no significant price increases in Austria and only a modest rise in the Netherlands. More recent price index data through December 2015 suggests prices continued to decline across 2015 as MVNOs and sub-brands intensified competition, with new entrants like Hofer Telekom, eety and Yooopi! contributing to downward pressure on retail prices.
It remains uncertain whether Three’s latest package of concessions—price freezes, major network investment and the proposed network carve-up for Sky and Virgin Media—will be sufficient to satisfy regulators. The key questions regulators will weigh include whether the proposed access arrangements genuinely preserve competition, whether new and existing MVNOs can use the network on equally favorable terms, and how the market will evolve in terms of prices, investment and consumer choice if the merger goes ahead.
As the review continues, stakeholders across the industry and consumers alike will be watching closely. The outcome could set an important precedent for how future large-scale mergers in the telecoms sector are assessed and conditioned.
Do you think Hutchison’s concessions should be enough? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.