(Image Credit: iStockPhoto/Maxiphoto)
Although the market offers a wide range of impressive smart devices, the absence of a common standard has left many products operating independently rather than working together. Based on personal experience, this fragmentation has dampened my enthusiasm for expanding a smart home setup.
A new report from Argus Insights indicates that I’m not alone: overall consumer demand for smart home technology is declining. This trend contrasts with individual device satisfaction, which has been gradually improving, albeit modestly.
According to the report, consumer distrust in the reliability of connected devices is a major barrier to broader adoption. That reduced confidence could make it difficult for manufacturers to achieve strong holiday-season sales, particularly after a previous cycle in which first-time buyers encountered frustrating installation and usability problems.
“These devices are still designed more for the Internet of Things than the Internet of Humans. Mainstream consumers were burned last holiday season by installation and reliability issues and though the remaining consumers in the market overall like these products more, the issues that forced out mainstream adopters after Holiday 2014 remain,” said John Feland, CEO of Argus Insights. “Our analysis suggests that 2015 may be less than robust for smart home devices.”
Devices that lead in consumer satisfaction include smart light bulbs, home security kits, and connected thermostats. Security cameras, by contrast, have delivered the most consistent disappointment, experiencing widespread reliability and performance complaints.
Among security camera offerings, SimpliSafe ranks highest in consumer satisfaction due to its straightforward installation, intuitive user experience, and strong value. Canary initially followed closely but has seen satisfaction drop recently as users report connection problems that render the device unusable at times.
Nest, widely known for its popular smart thermostat, struggled more with its security camera launch. Nest Cam’s satisfaction ratings have improved nearly 20% since its initial release as several early problems were addressed; however, many users still find its notifications and streaming reliability insufficient for trusted everyday use.
The research makes clear that smart devices still need to become more human-centered to persuade a broader audience of their practical value. Products like Nest Cam demonstrate it’s still possible to win back consumer trust through improvements, but for some brands that turnaround may come too late to affect the upcoming holiday buying season.
You can obtain the full “Smart Home Delight” report from Argus Insights for more detailed findings.
What has been your experience with smart home devices? Share your thoughts in the comments.